There are several factors leading to this decision. Primarily we feel that your perception of the character in this application is not substantial enough. There is a great focus on Anderson's faith throughout the application, but it is only covered on a basic level (i.e., he is not denoted as Catholic whereas this is important within the canon). While you have captured his personality in an abbreviated sense, there is not enough given to show a full understanding of the character and his relationship with fellow canon-mates, nor enough information on Anderson's abilities or affiliations.

This, in addition to a lack of denoted canon point are among the main reasons which have led to this decision.